Employee Screenings Save Your Business ... and May Save a Life

">haul.
Staffing vendors who refer candidates on theDigging deeper into credit history is another step
strength of a resume and a phoneyou can take take–especially for candidates
interview—foregoing thorough backgroundassign to financial industry accounts.
checks–are asking for trouble.“If you care about the quality that
Case in point from the CEO of Palmiter Recruitingyou’re presenting, especially to financial
of Plymouth, Minnesota: 15 years ago, before sheinstitutions, we need to know who we’re
founded her staffing company, Elizabeth Palmitersubmitting," says Tony Williamson, president of
was on assignment as a contractor herself whenGolden Valley, Minnesota-based vendor Ajasa
the nightmare of nightmares occurred at a client'sTechnologies, Otherwise you risk losing the
worksite.business on one bad apple. ”An employer
During a routine reference check, a contractordoesn't want to run the risk that an employee
marched into his supervisor’s office andover his head in financial debt will be tempted to
killed him with an automatic rifle.steal from a banking customer.
The scary thing is that because it was anPerfecting the personal reference check
automatic rifle, he could have killed other people,You should always check references to support a
too,” says Palmiter.hiring decision. Unfortunately, this is made harder
Today, Palmiter works on the other side of theby the litigious nature of the corporate world.
desk–as a staffing vendor for tier-oneMany companies are reluctant to do much more
companies in Minneapolis-St. Paul. Impossible tothan verify a former employee’s job title
forget, experiencing workplace violence first-handand dates of employment, for fear that a
has made Palmiter diligent about checking thecandidate will sue them for providing a poor
backgrounds of all candidates—whether thereference.
hiring company requires it or not.You should be prepared to be creative when
The same isn’t true at all staffingcalling references. Here are a couple of
companies.suggestions that have worked for others.
According to a recent report from Taleo1. Work through your network -
Research, only 33 percent of companies conductIn the course of the conversation about the
background checks on employees. The loss ofcandidate’s background, try to identify
human life is a rare and extreme consequence ofreferences that you and the candidate have in
not vetting prospective employees andcommon. This is easier for the seasoned recruiter
contractors. More commonly, staffing vendorswho personally knows hundreds of people in
may face legal action, damage to businesscompanies across a market or sector and a
reputation, loss of clients and revenue andvalue-add that can help sell your worth to client
negative media coverage if they fail to thoroughlycompanies.
screen prospective candidates.2. Broaden your search -
Criminal background checks are insufficientYou can also contact the given references and
Even when you do perform a criminal recordsask them to suggest others who might have
check, keep in mind that it probably isn’texperience with the candidate, offers Joseph
sufficient protection.Golemo, a branch manager with Minneapolis-based
National background checks don’t reveal allENRGi Consulting. Everyone knows the people on
the offenses on record, according to newsthe first list will give a good reference to the
reports [ as there is no national database ofcandidate, so you call them and ask some cursory
felony convictions. Criminal records are filed inquestions,” says Golemo. “Then get
more than 3,100 courthouses throughout theto the real purpose of the call, which is to ask:
United States reporting processes can differ‘Is there anyone else I can speak to that
widely, making it difficult and costly to guaranteewill be able to provide a reference for this
that a new hire isn’t a law breaker.candidate?’.”This second-tier
27 percent of organizations surveyed said theyreference will not have been coached or prepped
had suffered serious damages due to a flawedby the candidate, so will probably provide a more
records check, according to Taleo Research.balanced view of the candidate’s
Some of the consequences included workplacebackground and capabilities.
fraud (10 percent), employee theft (10 percent),3. Verifying identity -
workplace violence (7 percent).Still, with all the rigors of a criminal history check,
So while you should always contract a reputablepersonal interviews, drug screenings, credit checks
credential checking service, such as Verifiedand reference checks, some companies are
Credentials, StaffingCheck or ADT, you shouldstarting to take their screen processes a step
complement those reports with additionalfurther—to verify the identity of the
investigations, including:candidate.
- credit checksThese companies have their consultants and
- drug testspotential hires fingerprinted at a local bank or
- in-person interviewspolice station, according to Golemo.
- informal reference checksFingerprinting candidates foils the possibility that an
- technical interviews Nothing replaces theindividual may attempt to borrow the identity of
personal interviewanother worker in order to get a job they would
A 20-year veteran in the staffing industry, Rickbe otherwise unqualified to perform.
Kuula, president of Stillwater, Minnesota-basedIt works like this: The candidate is fingerprinted
staffing vendor Solutia Consulting, Inc. meets withduring the screening process. Then on the first
every consultant during the hiring process.day one the job, the new hire is fingerprinted
Though a technical screening is part ofagain to ensure the candidate’s fingerprints
Kuula’s review process, it’s not thematch the prints on file.
main focus.It may seem extreme and time-consuming, but it
If we have a feeling that there’salso ensures you’re providing the best,
something not right with the candidate and wecleanest candidate for a project. In the long run, it
can’t put a handle on it, we’reprotects you from the negative consequences of
better not to pursue it after the firstmaking a bad referral, and can preserve a good
contact,” says Kuula.client relationship for years to come.
It’s not rocket science. It’s spendingBeing rigorous also sends a clear message to a
time with the candidate to get to knowhiring company. “It shows that we’re
them,” says Kuula. The personal touchnot just throwing resumes over the
helps to insure that the candidate is a good fit forfence,” says Palmiter. “It shows that
the hiring company’s culture and thewe’re doing our jobs and that we’re
staffing vendor’s talent pool for the longa valuable resource.